Hi all!
It feels there is room to converge on how on-chain votes in Tally are reported or counted towards participation and communication thresholds.
I was taking them into account in my last report, as I think most of us did. However, they may be missing in Dec/Jan reporting.
It is my opinion that Tally proposals should be in scope since compensation is aligned with governance participation, and on-chain vote is an additional governance exercise to that of snapshot (and finally what gets executed on-chain).
In any case, I will report it both ways, as I don’t want to slow things down. I will edit and remove the one not required after consensus is reached.
11th Dec 22 to 10th Jan 23
Without Tally
Period Participation: 2/2 (HIP-4 amendment , HIP-13) - 100%
Period Communication: 2/2 (HIP-4 amendment, HIP-13) - 100%
Cumulative Participation = 6/8 = 75%
Cumulative Communication = 6/8 = 75%
Penalty: (90%-75%)*3 = 45%
Lowest for the period: 158,713.23
Formula incentives: 2,277.14 * (100% - 45%) = 1,252.427
With Tally:
Period Participation: 4/4 (HIP-4 amendment Snapshot , HIP-13 Snapshot, HIP-9 Tally, HIP-12 Tally) - 100%
Period Communication: 4/4 (HIP-4 amendment, HIP-13) - 100%
Cumulative Participation = 8/10 = 80%
Cumulative Communication = 8/10 = 80%
(For visibility, missed HIP8 snapshot vote, and HIP10 on-chain vote).
Penalty: (90%-80%)*3 = 30%
Lowest for the period: 158,713.23
Formula incentives: 2,277.14 * (100% - 30%) = 1,593.99
0x8C5f9c67028fAaE0Db258D44507BdfBD7A9de223 - mrsisyphos.eth
[Edit 1] Forgot to include the different penalties.